Food & Drink · Seafood
Fins at Sharky’s
About
Fins at Sharky’s occupies the upper level of the same beachfront building as Sharky’s on the Pier, at the south end of Venice Beach where the sand meets the base of the city’s fishing pier. Where the downstairs restaurant runs a casual, high volume beach bar menu, Fins takes a more polished, upscale approach to the same waterfront location, aimed at diners looking for a sit down dinner rather than a quick bite between beach activities. The elevated dining room takes advantage of its position, giving guests a wide view across the Gulf of Mexico that makes it one of the more sought after sunset dinner reservations in Venice.
The menu focuses on Gulf seafood and steaks prepared with more attention than a typical beach bar kitchen, catering to visitors marking a special occasion, an anniversary dinner, or simply willing to pay for a quieter, more refined version of the same waterfront setting that draws crowds downstairs. Venice’s identity as a beach town is closely tied to this stretch of shoreline, home to the Venice Fishing Pier and within a short drive of Caspersen Beach, one of the best known spots in Florida for finding fossilized shark teeth that wash up from the Miocene era deposits underlying the Gulf Coast here.
Sharing a building and ownership group with Sharky’s on the Pier, Fins benefits from the same three-plus decades of history on this specific stretch of beach, giving it an established local reputation even as a somewhat separate concept from its downstairs neighbor. The restaurant’s elevated position also offers some shelter from the busier, louder atmosphere at beach level, appealing to diners who want the same sunset view without the full volume of a beach bar crowd.
Being on Venice Island, within walking distance of public beach parking and the fishing pier, Fins draws both tourists staying nearby and Sarasota County residents making a special trip for dinner with a view. As an independently owned business rooted specifically in this location, Fins at Sharky’s has become one of the more reliable answers in Venice for a memorable sunset dinner directly on the Gulf.
The Venice Fishing Pier just below the restaurant has anchored this stretch of shoreline for decades, rebuilt more than once after storm damage, and anglers working the pier at dusk often become part of the scene visible from Fins’ elevated dining room. Venice’s identity as the self described Shark Tooth Capital of the World traces to the fossil beds beneath beaches like Caspersen just south of here, a Miocene era deposit that continually washes ancient shark teeth onto the sand, and a restaurant built around the same name and setting draws directly on that local distinction, offering diners a polished version of the same waterfront experience that makes the beach itself a destination.