The Florida Guide
Seafood
Fresh seafood from casual fish shacks to white-tablecloth dining rooms. These are the best independently owned seafood restaurants in the area, sourcing close to home and cooking it right.
96 places
Filter by area
$
The Freezer Tiki Bar
Steamed shrimp and cold beer at a working fish house
Locally Owned
Outdoor Seating
Waterfront
$$
Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar
Seafood and sushi on a Marathon canal
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Keys Fisheries
Working fish house famous for the lobster Reuben
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Outdoor Seating
$$
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar
Clam chowder, crab and a backyard tiki bar on south Siesta Key
Dine-in
Full Bar
Live Music
$$
Siesta Key Oyster Bar
Oysters, cold drinks and live music in Siesta Key Village
Dine-in
Full Bar
Live Music
$$$
The Sandbar Restaurant
Toes-in-the-sand seafood on the Gulf at Anna Maria
Beachfront
Dine-in
Full Bar
$$
Timoti’s Seafood Shak
Wild-caught seafood baskets and tacos a block off Centre Street
Dine-in
Family Friendly
Locally Owned
$$
Nini Seafood
Locally Owned
Takeout
$
Miles Seafood & Chicken
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Northwest Seafood Outlet
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Crab Man 305
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Los Ranchos Sea Food Restaurant
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$$
Water Oak Grill
Full Bar
Locally Owned
Private Events
$$
The Tides Seafood Market & Provisions
Locally Owned
$$$
Kretch’s Restaurant
Locally Owned
$$
Mister Crab Cakes
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$$
Cafe de Marco
Locally Owned
$$
Cocomo’s Grill
Locally Owned
$$
LeeBeFish
Delivery
Locally Owned
$$
Lighthouse Seafood
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Victorio’s Oyster Bar and Grille
Dine-in
Family Owned
Full Bar
$
Glades Snapper
Family Owned
Locally Owned
Takeout
$
Mr Shrimps
Family Owned
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
The Green Marlin Restaurant & Raw Bar
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$$
The Captain’s Tavern Restaurant
Dine-in
Locally Owned
$$
Mariscos El Pulpo 2
Locally Owned
$$
Crazy Fish Bar & Grill
Dine-in
Locally Owned
O’Shucks Oyster Bar & Grill
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
Rita’s Oyster Bar
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Hurricane Charley’s Sushi, Raw Bar and Grill
Full Bar
Live Music
Waterfront
$$
Laishley Crab House
Full Bar
Gluten-Free Options
Live Music
Riverwalk at Tin City
Family Friendly
Live Music
Locally Owned
Bayside Seafood Grill & Bar
Family Owned
Locally Owned
Waterfront
La Pescheria
Locally Owned
Outdoor Seating
Pet Friendly
$$$
Sails Restaurant
Full Bar
Live Music
Locally Owned
Sea Salt
Happy Hour
Live Music
Locally Owned
$$
Local Steamer Seafood Market
Locally Owned
Harpoon Harry’s
Locally Owned
$$
Saltwater Grill
Locally Owned
$$
Mike’s Cafe and Oyster Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Angry Tuna Seafood Company
Locally Owned
Sealand Restaurant
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Tiki West Raw Bar and Grill
Locally Owned
Sam’s Seafood Market & Oyster Bar
Free Parking
Locally Owned
Yummy Crab Seafood Restaurant & Sports Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Riverside Seafood Market & Restaurant
The Great Catch
The Chowder House Restaurant
The Conch Shack
Red Shoe Island Bistro
B.O.’s Fish Wagon
Edgewater Fish and Wings
Family Friendly
Takeout
$$
Rusty Bellies Waterfront Grill
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$
Pelican Point Seafood
Locally Owned
Takeout
Waterfront
CJ’s Seafood Company
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
Shucker Tom’s Raw Bar
Full Bar
Locally Owned
The Troff
Family Owned
Live Music
Locally Owned
$$
Shuck N Ale
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Left Coast Seafood Co
Locally Owned
$$
Myakka River Oyster Bar
Full Bar
Locally Owned
Waterfront
$$
Sharky’s on the Pier
Beachfront
Full Bar
Live Music
$$$
Fins at Sharky’s
Beachfront
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$$
Crow’s Nest Marina Restaurant & Tavern
Full Bar
Locally Owned
Waterfront
$$
Autumn’s Crab
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
Legend Seafood
Locally Owned
$
Dr. Limon Ceviche Bar
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Crabby’s Bar & Grill NSB
Full Bar
Happy Hour
Locally Owned
$$
PJ’s Sea Shack
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Off the Hook Raw Bar and Grill
Full Bar
Happy Hour
Locally Owned
$$
Jensen Brothers Seafood
Locally Owned
$$
Lucky Lobster Co
Catering
Locally Owned
Outdoor Seating
$$
Sea Sea Riders
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Lakes Community Ballroom and Restaurant
Dine-in
Live Music
Locally Owned
$$
Kickin Crawfish
Dine-in
Full Bar
Live Music
$$
Carl’s Seafood
Catering
Delivery
Dine-in
$$
Chef Pat’s Seafood & Grill
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$
Gene’s Oyster Bar
Historic Building
Locally Owned
$
GetChewaBox Street Kitchen
Locally Owned
$$
Mansta Seafood Deli
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Coconuts on the Beach
Full Bar
Locally Owned
Outdoor Seating
$$
Two Drunken Goats
Full Bar
Happy Hour
Live Music
$$
Seafood Station
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$$
The Magnolia Oyster Bar
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Interocean Seafood
Locally Owned
$$
Dr. Limon Ceviche Bar
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$$
Kerry’s by the Sea
Full Bar
Happy Hour
Locally Owned
$
TASTY Bakery
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Dave’s Last Resort & Raw Bar
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Rodbenders Rawbar
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Kitchens Seafood
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$
Linda’s Crab Shack
Dine-in
Locally Owned
Takeout
$$$
Nicole’s Seafood & Prime Rib
Dine-in
Family Owned
Locally Owned
$$
Riptides Raw Bar & Grill
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
$$
Lulu’s Oceanside Grill
Dine-in
Full Bar
Locally Owned
Salimar Ceviche Bar
Locally Owned
Bar Harbor Seafood
Locally Owned
No listings match those filters
Try a different area or remove a filter.