Boutique Hotels & Inns

The Paradise Inn

Florida Keys · Key West
Happy Hour Locally Owned Pool

About

The Paradise Inn occupies a Simonton Street lot in Old Town that once housed a cigar factory, a history the property nods to with a set of cottages styled after cigar makers’ quarters from that era. The mix of cottages and suites gives guests more variety than a standard hotel room layout, and the gardens between the buildings are dense enough to give each unit a reasonable sense of privacy despite the compact lot.

The inn is adults-only and leans into a relaxed, romantic atmosphere, with a Jacuzzi and a tropical pool as the main gathering spots on the property. A nightly wine and cheese happy hour is included, along with a continental breakfast each morning, both standard features among Key West’s boutique inns but genuinely well executed here according to repeat guests.

Simonton Street runs close enough to Duval Street, the Hemingway Home and Mallory Square that guests can reach any of them on foot in a matter of minutes, while the inn’s gated grounds stay quiet enough to sleep through the later hours. The Paradise Inn picked up a TripAdvisor Traveler’s Choice Award in 2023, a reflection of consistent guest satisfaction rather than any single headline amenity.

For couples looking for an adults-only, garden-set boutique stay with genuine cigar-era history behind it, The Paradise Inn offers a distinctive setting without straying from the compact, independently run guesthouse format that defines so much of Key West’s Old Town lodging scene.

Simonton Street runs a fairly direct route between Duval Street and the Historic Seaport, so guests staying here have an easy choice between the two most popular areas of Old Town depending on the evening’s plans. Because the cottages were built to echo the cigar workers’ housing that once stood on or near the site, the layouts tend to be more compact and self-contained than the standard rooms, which suits couples who want a bit more privacy for the length of a stay. The nightly happy hour has become enough of a fixture that repeat guests sometimes plan their evening around it before heading out to dinner elsewhere in Old Town.

Accessible rooms are available for guests who need them, a detail worth confirming directly given how much historic Key West lodging is built around older structures with uneven floors or narrow doorways that cannot always accommodate every need. The adults-only policy keeps the pool area and common spaces calm throughout the day, which fits the general romantic, low-key positioning the inn has built its reputation around.