Pizza & Italian

Toby’s Pizza & Subs

Daytona and the Space Coast · Edgewater
Delivery Takeout

About

Toby’s Pizza & Subs has anchored the Florida Shores neighborhood of Edgewater for about 24 years, tucked along West Indian River Boulevard in a stretch of town that is more residential than commercial, which makes it feel like a true neighborhood pizzeria rather than a stop for passing tourists. The shop specializes in the two things its name promises, New York style pizza by the slice or the pie, and hot and cold submarine sandwiches piled with deli meats and cheese.

Regulars single out the pizza for its generous cheese and simple, homemade quality rather than anything fussy or overworked, the kind of pie that tastes like it came from a family recipe passed down rather than a corporate formula. The sub menu covers the standard Italian combinations along with steak and cheese and meatball options, served on rolls that hold up to a full lunch rather than falling apart halfway through. Toby’s earns a strong reputation locally for its slice specials, an affordable lunch option that keeps the shop busy on weekdays when people are looking for something fast that still feels like a real meal.

The restaurant keeps a practical schedule, open from late morning through dinner Monday through Saturday, with slightly extended hours on Friday and Saturday nights to cover the weekend crowd. Takeout and deli style service are the focus here rather than a sit down dining experience, matching the character of a shop that has built its following on convenience and consistency rather than atmosphere. Payment is accepted across all the major cards, and the shop has built up enough of a following over two decades that it shows up reliably in local pizza recommendations for the Edgewater and New Smyrna Beach area.

For residents of Florida Shores in particular, Toby’s functions as the default pizza order, the place people call without needing to check a menu because they already know what they want. That kind of default status in a neighborhood is not won overnight, and Toby’s slow accumulation of regulars over more than two decades says more about the food than any marketing could. Anyone new to Edgewater looking for an independent pizza and sub shop away from the chain options on Ridgewood Avenue will find Toby’s a solid, unfussy choice for a fast, familiar meal.

Because the shop sits away from the more heavily trafficked commercial plazas, parking is rarely an issue, and the pace tends to be unhurried even during a lunch rush. Visitors exploring Edgewater’s residential streets for the first time, or families settled into the Florida Shores area, will find Toby’s an easy, low key stop for a fast meal that does not sacrifice the feel of a real, family run kitchen.